Our Dinner Menu
Classic Chicago supper club choices, elevated. Try a new experience with an old favorite.
Appetizers
Start your Tortoise experience with our Relish Tray served in true supper club fashion on a spinning lazy Susan.
Oysters on the Half Shell* 24.95 GF
Nonesuch Oysters from Maine served with Bloody Mary Sauce | Half Dozen
Colossal Shrimp Cocktail* 22.95 GF
Bloody Mary Cocktail Sauce
Relish Tray 17.95
Marinated Olives, White Balsamic, Mushrooms, Pimento Cheese and Pretzel Toast, Bread and Butter Pickles, Golden Beets, House-Made Mixed Nuts
Buttermilk “Shore Lunch” Calamari 17.95
Arrabbiata Sauce, Calabrese Chilis
Steak Tartare* 23.95
Pickled Chilis, Basil Chimichurri
Oyster St. Charles 19.95GF
Crispy Fried Oysters, Creamed Spinach, Honey Mustard Aoli
Baked Shrimp Scampi Dip 12.95
Parmesan Breadcrumbs, Ritz Crackers
Seared Ahi Tuna* 24.95GF
Sesame Crusted, Mango Salsa, Miso
Lambchop Lollipops 29.95GF
Mint Chimichurri
Begin your experience with our Tortoise Signature Bread, Boule Stuffed with Mascarpone and Gorgonzola Cheeses, and drizzled with Garlic Butter. 3.95 each.
Soup & Salads
LOBSTER BISQUE 15.95
Fresh Lobster Meat
Classic Caesar Salad 11.95
Spicy Caesar Dressing, White Anchovies, Parmesan Cheese, Parmesan Crouton, Fried Chestnuts
Hydro Boston Bibb Salad 9.95 GF V
Ranch Vinaigrette, Parmesan Frico
Chopped Wedge Salad 12.95
Applewood Bacon, Danish Blue Cheese, Grape Tomato, Croutons
Burrata & Heirloom Tomato Salad 15.95 GF V
Balsamic Vinaigrette, Pesto, Pistachio
Sides
Great for sharing.
Buttery Mashed Potatoes 7.95ea GF V
5 Cheese Mac & Cheese 9.95V
Creamed Spinach 11.95GF V
Grilled Asparagus 11.95 GF V
Black Truffle Béarnaise
Broccolini 11.95 GF V
Olive Oil, Garlic, Red Chili Flakes
Rosemary Frites 7.95 GF V
Seafood
The freshest seafood.
Skuna Bay Salmon 34.95
Sweet Corn Relish, Mint Chimichurri
Pan Seared Sea Scallops 39.95 GF
Green Pea Risotto, Asparagus, Artichokes
Chilean Sea Bass 49.95 GF
Sautéed Watercress and Ginger, Coconut Rice, Shrimp Ragout
Dover Sole Meunière 58.95
Served Pan Sauteed, Sauce Meuniere, Fresh Lemon
Steaks & Chops
We Proudly Serve 40 Day Wet Aged Prime Steak from Allen Brothers of Chicago
10 oz. Prime Skirt Steak 39.95 GF
Bourbon Barrel Worcestershire, Grilled Onions, Buttery Mashed Potatoes
10 oz. Prime Filet Mignon 59.95 GF
Maitre d’Hotel Butter
10 oz. Prime Filet Oscar 76.95 GF
King Crab, Asparagus, Bernaise Sauce
14 oz. Prime New York Strip Steak Au Poivre 62.95 GF
Cognac Peppercorn Sauce
Braised Short Ribs 36.95
Red Wine Demi-Glaze, Baby Carrots, Buttery Mashed Potatoes
Beef Wellington 63.95
10 oz. Prime Filet Wrapped in a Buttery Puff Pastry with a Crimini Mushroom, Prosciuto, Chestnuts, Duxelle
Steak Add-Ons
Black Truffle Béarnaise 3.95 GF
Maitre d’Hotel Butter 3.95 GF
Cognac Peppercorn Sauce 3.95 GF
Friday & Saturday Special
Prime Rib King Cut
58.95 GF
Chef Pablo seasons the Prime Rib with Lawry’s Seasoning, then, peels back the cap, seasons it again with Lawry’s and chopped rosemary, then slow cooks the beef for 12 hours and serves it with Horseradish Cream, Rosemary Jus, and House Steak Salt.
TSC Entrées
A few Supper Club favorites.
Eggplant Pizzette 28.95 V
Aged Gouda Breading, Tomato Coulis, Fontina Gratinee, Marinara
TSC Cheeseburger 19.95
Cheddar Cheese, Grilled Onions, Brioche Bun, Kennebec Frites
Oak Aged Bourbon Barrel Meatloaf 25.95
Foraged Mushrooms, Buttery Mashed Potatoes
Roasted Acorn Squash and Vegetable Risotto 23.95 GF V
Garlic Parmesan, Pinenuts
Make a Dinner Reservation
Enjoy the cuisine and cocktails made from scratch, and settle into the swanky, supper club, jazz era vibe. Come for dinner or make a night of it. Endless possibilities await.
Drinks & Dessert
The perfect supper club experience is bookended by craft cocktails and from scratch desserts. Enjoy both during dinner or in the best lounge in Chicago at Tortoise Supper Club.
GF Denotes Gluten Free – 20% Gratuity Added to Parties of 8 or More
*Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, eggs, or unpasteurized milk may increase your risk of foodborne illness. There will be a 3% transaction fee added to all credit card transactions